Program Comprehension

Peer Review of Essay Draft: Instructions

Answer each question below (in order) on the notebook paper. In each case, suggest improvements if possible.

1. Your name?

2. Name of author?

3. Did they use the LaTeX template with the macros turned on?
   • Yes, No, Mostly, Somewhat
   • Indicate divergences
4. Were the instructions followed?
   • See https://memphis-cs.github.io/comp-7085-8085/essays/instructions.html
   • Indicate issues
5. Do the paragraphs flow smoothly?
   • Indicate breaks in flow
   • Pay particular attention to the topic sentences
6. Does the essay make sense?
   • Yes, No, Mostly, Somewhat
   • Indicate issues
7. How strong are the arguments being made?
   • Very strong, somewhat strong, somewhat weak, very weak
   • Indicate which arguments are particularly strong/weak
8. How complete is this draft?
   • Mostly complete, moderately complete, lots incomplete